Preparing for the Unexpected: Clauses for Unforeseen Circumstances in Divorce

published on 01 February 2024

Most would agree that divorce agreements aim to provide stability amidst life's unpredictability.

Yet traditional divorce agreements often fail to account for unforeseen circumstances that later arise.

This article explores specialized contract clauses that help prepare for the unexpected in divorce, promoting durability and equity even amidst unbargained-for losses.

Introduction to Unforeseen Circumstances in Divorce

This section provides an overview of the importance of planning for unexpected events in divorce agreements.

Understanding the Impact of Unexpected Circumstances

Unexpected changes during divorce proceedings can lead to complications if not addressed upfront. For example, a job loss or change in child custody can greatly impact finances and arrangements. Proactively including clauses to account for surprises can help reduce issues down the road.

The Limitations of Traditional Divorce Agreements

Standard divorce agreements often fail to anticipate changes in employment, incomes, or other unpredictable factors. This makes the agreements less adaptable if circumstances change. More robust agreements are needed.

Emphasizing the Need for Preparedness

Given the likelihood of unforeseen events, divorce agreements should try to mitigate risks by outlining processes to handle surprises. This demonstrates proper preparedness and flexibility to support all parties if the unexpected occurs. The goal is divorce terms that withstand volatility.

Incorporating Clauses for Impossibility and Impracticability

Divorce agreements can be complex, with many moving parts. To account for unexpected changes that could undermine the agreement, lawyers should consider including clauses that allocate obligations if certain conditions become impossible or impracticable to fulfill.

Understanding Impracticability in Divorce Clauses

Impracticability clauses outline options if a material condition in the divorce agreement becomes extremely difficult or impossible to satisfy. For example, if one spouse was required to pay the other a certain amount but then faces financial hardship, these clauses could provide alternatives like lowering payments or extending deadlines. They aim to fairly adjust the agreement rather than voiding it entirely.

Addressing Frustration of Purpose in Divorce

Frustration of purpose clauses deal with situations where a fundamental purpose behind the divorce agreement is destroyed, making it pointless to continue the contract. For instance, if the agreement centered on one spouse retaining ownership of a business that later goes bankrupt. These clauses provide a legal exit in cases where insisting the contract continues as-is would impose an unreasonable burden compared to what the parties envisioned.

Drafting Force Majeure Clauses in Divorce Agreements

Force majeure refers to extraordinary events beyond a party's control which prevent them from fulfilling divorce agreement obligations. This could include natural disasters, war, or government actions. These clauses excuse non-performance during force majeure events, while outlining steps such as good faith efforts to restore ability to perform when the events pass. They provide protection from litigation if unexpected catastrophes undermine divorce agreement conditions down the line.


Strategies for Drafting Clauses Amidst Unbargained-for Losses

Divorce can bring many unexpected changes and losses. Careful planning when drafting the separation agreement can help reduce future conflicts.

Anticipating a Range of Unforeseen Scenarios

Consider how changes in employment, health, or family status could impact the division of assets and obligations. Discuss hypothetical situations and compromise solutions in advance. Being proactive builds goodwill and prevents costly legal battles down the road.

Clearly Defining Triggering Events for Clauses

Precisely outline the circumstances allowing contract changes. For example, define key terms like "disability", "job loss", "relocation", etc. Ambiguous language risks future disagreements over intent and enforcement.

Equitable Allocation of Burden Under Impracticability

If meeting the original agreement becomes impractical or impossible, the burden should be shared fairly based on factors like income and dependents. For example, child support could be reduced for a period of unemployment. The key is balancing compassion and accountability.

Drafting for unknowns requires creativity and compromise. Focusing on equitable solutions will lead to agreements that withstand unexpected changes. With thoughtful planning, you can reduce future conflicts down the road.

Aligning Unforeseen Circumstances Clauses with Tacit Assumptions

When drafting unforeseen circumstances clauses in a divorce agreement, it's important to ensure alignment with the tacit assumptions underlying the original terms. Here are some tips:

Ensuring Consistency With Other Agreement Terms

  • Carefully review child custody, spousal maintenance, and other existing provisions. Analyze how triggering the unforeseen circumstances clause could impact these arrangements.

  • Draft the clause to explicitly reference and account for interdependencies with other terms, aiming to minimize conflicts or inconsistencies.

  • Consider carving out certain essential provisions from the scope of the clause to maintain stability in critical areas.

Contemplating the Relationship To Governing Law

  • Research how choice of law provisions may affect enforceability and interpretation of unforeseen circumstances clauses.

  • Weigh risks of uncertainty stemming from gaps or conflicts between the clause and governing law.

  • Specify which state or country's laws will be used to supplement and clarify application of the clause.

Integrating Dispute Resolution Processes

  • Coordinate the unforeseen circumstances clause with specified mediation, arbitration, or other dispute resolution mechanisms.

  • Designate a neutral third party to help interpret the clause if good faith disagreements arise between parties.

  • Outline a streamlined process for rapidly invoking the clause when warranted by events, minimizing procedural delays.

Careful integration of unforeseen circumstances clauses, grounded in the foundational assumptions of the divorce agreement, can provide stability amidst life's unpredictability. With some forethought, these provisions can flexibly sustain the original divorce terms even as unexpected situations unfold.

Conclusion: Preparing for the Impracticable and the Unforeseen

As we have seen, divorce agreements can be complex, with many moving parts. However, by proactively including robust clauses to account for unexpected circumstances, lawyers can better serve their clients.

Summary of Core Takeaways

  • Unforeseen events like pandemics can significantly impact divorce settlements in unanticipated ways. Careful planning is essential.
  • "Impossibility" and "impracticability" clauses can help account for radically changed conditions.
  • Provisions for "unbargained-for losses" can aid with addressing unanticipated financial impacts.
  • Tacit assumption and frustration clauses also have potential to add helpful flexibility.

Future Prospects for Divorce Agreements

As case law continues to evolve, more options may emerge for building adaptable and resilient divorce agreements. Lawyers would do well to stay abreast of legal developments in this area.

Related posts

Read more