Severability Clauses: Ensuring Contract Validity

published on 01 February 2024

Creating valid contracts is critical, yet tricky. It's easy to overlook details that could render agreements unenforceable.

Using severability clauses helps ensure contract validity by allowing intact provisions to remain in force if certain sections are challenged.

This article explains what severability clauses are, outlines key benefits, provides examples, and summarizes best practices for crafting effective severability provisions to support overall contract validity.

Introduction to Severability Clauses

A severability clause aims to preserve contract validity if certain provisions are deemed invalid or unenforceable. This section will introduce key concepts around severability clauses, their purpose, and benefits for contract drafting.

Defining Severability Clauses

A severability clause, also known as a salvatorius clause, is a provision in a contract that states if any part of the contract is found to be illegal or unenforceable, the remainder of the contract will still be valid and enforceable.

Essentially, a severability clause acts as a safeguard to preserve the validity of a contract if certain clauses or provisions are struck down or deemed unenforceable by a court of law. It severs the unenforceable parts from the contract while allowing the remaining provisions to survive.

Explaining the Purpose

Severability clauses serve a few key purposes in contract drafting:

  • Preserve contract validity if parts are invalidated - This ensures the entire contract does not get thrown out if certain clauses are found to be problematic. The remaining intact portions of the agreement can still be enforced.

  • Limit future disputes and uncertainty - Adding a severability clause provides clarity upfront on how the contract should be interpreted if provisions are severed. This prevents potential future disagreements over the status of the rest of the contract.

  • Support good faith agreements - Severability clauses allow parties entering an agreement in good faith to still realize the intended benefits of valid contract provisions, even if some aspects require adjustment.

Outlining Key Benefits

The main benefits of including a severability clause in a contract include:

  • Maintains parties' original intent and desired exchange to the furthest extent possible
  • Reduces risk of entire contract being invalidated due to a single problematic clause
  • Limits future disputes and supports good faith contracting
  • Provides contractual stability if regulatory or legal changes occur
  • Allows easier amendments and modifications to contract over time

Overall, severability clauses offer an important safeguard for contract validity and enforceability over the long-term. They provide flexibility to evolve agreements while still preserving parties' original goals and benefits.

What does a severability clause in a contract ensure?

A severability clause, also known as a salvatorious clause, is an important provision in a contract that aims to preserve the validity of the agreement in case one part of it is found to be unenforceable or invalid.

Here are three key things a severability clause ensures:

  • Continued Enforceability - The severability clause allows the rest of the contract terms and provisions to remain valid and binding even if one clause is struck down. This prevents the entire contract from being voided.

  • Limits Risk - With a severability clause, there is less risk of losing the entire agreement due to one problematic term. This provides more security to both parties.

  • Supports Intent - Courts will try to uphold the original intent of the contract as much as possible. The severability clause assists judges in enforcing the remaining terms according to that intent.

In summary, adding a severability clause is an important way for contract parties to mitigate risks and preserve the enforceability of their agreement if issues emerge with any specific terms down the road. It helps support the overall initial intent. Legal teams aim to craft contracts that withstand legal scrutiny, and severability clauses provide that added layer of protection.

What is the 13 severability clause?

The severability clause, also known as the savings clause, is an important provision in contracts that aims to preserve the validity of the remaining sections of the contract if one section is deemed invalid or unenforceable.

The sample severability clause provided ("13. SEVERABILITY...") essentially states that if any part of the contract is found to be invalid or unconstitutional, it will not affect the validity and enforceability of the rest of the contract.

This protects the overall contract so that only the problematic portion is severed, while allowing the remaining provisions to survive. It avoids a situation where one problematic clause could invalidate the entire contract.

Including a severability clause provides a safeguard that preserves the intent of the contract as much as possible in case a section is contested. It demonstrates the parties' intent to move forward with the valid portions even if a phrase, sentence or section is removed.

The key benefit is to limit the damage and avoid wholesale invalidation of the contract if a particular term ends up being unenforceable for any reason. This provides more security to both parties that the core purpose and remaining substance of the contract will remain intact.

What are the clauses of a valid contract?

To write effective and enforceable business contracts, you need to include key contract clauses such as:

  • Indemnification clauses outline responsibilities if legal issues arise. They clarify who pays legal costs or damages.

  • Force majeure clauses excuse performance if unexpected events like natural disasters occur. This protects parties if obligations become impossible.

  • Copyright clauses state who owns intellectual property created under the contract. This prevents disputes over ownership rights.

  • Termination clauses let parties end agreements under certain conditions. This allows exiting contracts if serious issues emerge.

  • Warranties and disclaimers make guarantees or limit liability for products/services. This manages expectations around quality or performance.

  • Privacy clauses require protecting confidential data. This safeguards sensitive information like customer details.

Including robust clauses makes contracts more airtight. Work with legal counsel to ensure clauses align to local regulations and meet business needs. Prioritize clarity to prevent misunderstandings down the line.

sbb-itb-ba8dd7e

What will happen if a provision of the agreement is found to be invalid?

If any part, term or provision of a contract is determined to be invalid or unenforceable by a court of law, a severability or salvatorius clause helps preserve the remaining provisions. This clause states that if certain sections are found invalid, the rest of the contract remains legally binding and enforceable.

Here are some key things to know about severability clauses:

  • They allow the valid parts of an agreement to survive if some sections are invalidated. This prevents the entire contract from being voided.

  • They state that any provisions deemed unenforceable will be severed from the agreement, while all other provisions remain fully effective.

  • They ensure disputes over one clause won't undermine the overall intent and legality of the contract.

  • They give reassurance to both parties that the core purpose and obligations within the contract will remain intact if issues emerge later.

  • They typically use language stating the invalid terms are "severable" from the rest and that the remaining portions will continue with full force and effect.

Including a well-drafted severability clause provides a safeguard for contracts to avoid potential disputes or uncertainty down the road if any problematic clauses are challenged. It helps uphold parties' contracted obligations overall.

Crafting Effective Severability Clauses

This section explores best practices for drafting enforceable severability clauses in contracts. Severability clauses aim to preserve the validity of a contract even if certain provisions are deemed unenforceable. Carefully crafted severability clauses can increase the likelihood that the remaining contractual terms stay intact.

Key Elements to Include

When drafting a severability clause, be sure to include:

  • Explicit language stating that if a provision is found unenforceable, the remainder of the contract remains valid and binding.

  • Reference to any unenforceable "provision", "section", "paragraph", or "sentence" rather than the entire agreement. This allows only the problematic parts to be severed.

  • Specification that severance applies to the extent necessary for the contract to retain validity under applicable laws. This prevents over-severance.

  • A statement that both parties intend for the contract to be enforced even without the severed parts. This evidence of intent can aid enforceability.

Avoiding Pitfalls

Some common severability clause issues to avoid:

  • Using vague language about severability applying to "portions" of the contract. Courts may struggle determining what constitutes a severable portion.

  • Failing to reference state law governing contract interpretation. This could create confusion regarding what law applies.

  • Not specifically allowing both unilateral and joint severance. Some courts only allow both parties to jointly consent to severance.

Regional Differences

Requirements for severability clauses vary by jurisdiction:

  • In California, the clause must reference state law and allow for unilateral severance by a court. Joint severance is not always permitted.

  • New York largely allows contractual terms to determine severance. However, courts won't sever terms considered material or essential to the original agreement.

  • In contrast, Texas courts are more willing to sever material terms via a well-drafted severability clause without invalidating the entire contract.

Tailor severability clauses to your governing law to maximize enforceability. Consulting local counsel is advisable given nuances across regions.

Enforcing Severability Clauses

This section covers the process of invoking severability clauses during contract disputes and enforcing them through litigation.

Challenging Contract Provisions

If one party to a contract believes certain terms are invalid or unenforceable, they can challenge those specific provisions while allowing the remainder of the agreement to stand. This is made possible by including a severability clause.

To begin the process, the challenging party must formally notify the other party that they view certain contract terms as unlawful or unenforceable. They would then refuse to abide by those particular terms, while continuing to comply with the other unaffected sections of the contract.

The notified party can choose to revise the disputed sections or defend them in court. If brought to litigation, the fate of the challenged provisions would be decided by a judge.

Court Analysis Process

When a contract dispute over severability reaches the courts, judges undertake a two-step analysis:

  1. Evaluate Severability Clause - The judge first examines if the contract contains an enforceable severability provision stating that the unaffected contract terms can survive if certain sections are deemed invalid.

  2. Assess Provisions In Question - If a severability clause exists, the judge then analyzes the disputed contract terms to determine if they are unlawful or unenforceable for reasons such as ambiguity, duress, or conflict with statutes.

Courts aim to give effect to contractual severability clauses and strike only the problematic provisions while allowing the rest of the agreement to remain valid. The ultimate enforceability depends on the exact contract language and applicable laws.

Remedies and Contract Survival

If the court deems certain contract terms unenforceable and severs them as per a severability provision, common remedies include:

  • Removing the severed terms and enforcing the balance of the contract
  • Limiting the application of overly broad provisions to make them legally compliant
  • Interpreting the ambiguous sections in a reasonable manner

Without a severability clause, the potentially unenforceable terms could invalidate the entire contract. Its inclusion allows the agreement minus the severed elements to survive litigation intact. The court may award damages to compensate for losses related to the unenforceable sections.

Case Studies and Examples

This section provides real-world examples of severability clauses in action through case law analysis.

California Severability Clause Example

In a 2018 case in California, a severability clause was enforced to preserve the validity of an employment agreement after one provision was found to be unlawful and unenforceable. The court determined that the unlawful provision prohibiting former employees from working for competitors could be severed, allowing the remainder of the agreement to be upheld as valid. This demonstrates how severability clauses function under California contract law to save agreements that would otherwise fail entirely.

Enforcing Severability in Mergers & Acquisitions

A 2019 Delaware case examined the impact of a severability clause in a merger agreement between two telecommunications companies. The court found that several provisions related to regulatory approvals were invalid. However, due to the severability clause, the court severed those provisions and allowed the remainder of the $6 billion merger agreement to be completed. This shows how severability clauses can preserve complex M&A deals despite the partial invalidity of certain terms.

International Severability Approaches

The enforcement of severability clauses varies globally. For example, in France and Belgium, severability is only applied if the remaining contract can function without the invalid clause. Meanwhile, in China and Japan, courts take a more liberal approach, removing invalid clauses if the remainder of the contract reflects the original intent. Comparing international case law reveals nuances in interpreting and applying severability clauses across jurisdictions.

Conclusion and Key Takeaways

Severability clauses serve an important function in contracts by allowing unaffected provisions to remain valid if certain sections are deemed unenforceable. This helps preserve the overall intent and integrity of agreements.

Purpose and Benefits Review

Severability clauses aim to uphold broader contract validity if specific parts are challenged. Key advantages include:

  • Preserves unaffected sections if certain provisions are voided
  • Allows overall contract intent and terms to remain intact
  • Reduces legal disputes and rewriting of agreements
  • Provides flexibility if laws/regulations change

Best Practices Summary

When drafting severability provisions, best practices include:

  • Specify which state/jurisdiction's laws apply
  • Outline narrow severability parameters
  • Identify essential vs. non-essential terms
  • Use clear, unambiguous severability language
  • Place clause appropriately within contract

Final Thoughts

Well-crafted severability clauses demonstrate forethought regarding potential enforceability issues. They ultimately strengthen agreements against future disputes through built-in flexibility. Understanding their strategic use is key for validity.

Related posts

Read more