Most would agree that the impeachment of President Trump was an extraordinarily controversial and divisive event.
In this post, we will analyze the impeachment process and trial from an impartial, factual perspective, assessing its political and historical impacts without judgment.
We will examine the key events and figures surrounding the Trump-Ukraine scandal that triggered the impeachment inquiry, the articles of impeachment drafted by the House, the Senate trial and acquittal of the President, as well as the enduring political repercussions and unresolved questions in the aftermath.
The Impeachment of President Donald Trump in Retrospect
The Prelude to the Trump–Ukraine Scandal
In the months leading up to the Trump-Ukraine scandal, there were concerning actions taken by President Trump and his associates regarding Ukraine. This included the sudden removal of Marie Yovanovitch, the U.S. ambassador to Ukraine, in May 2019 after criticism from Rudy Giuliani and other Trump allies. There were also efforts by Trump's personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani to pressure Ukraine to investigate Trump's political rival Joe Biden and his son Hunter.
These actions set the stage for the July 25th phone call between President Trump and Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy that would ultimately trigger the impeachment inquiry.
The Whistleblower's Role in Sparking the Impeachment Inquiry Against Donald Trump
On August 12, 2019, an anonymous whistleblower from within the U.S. intelligence community filed a complaint regarding a phone call between President Trump and Ukrainian President Zelenskyy.
The whistleblower alleged that President Trump had pressured Zelenskyy during the July 25th phone call to investigate his political rival Joe Biden and Biden's son Hunter. This prompted concerns that Trump was soliciting foreign interference in the 2020 election for his own political benefit.
After the Inspector General determined the complaint was credible and an "urgent concern," the report was forwarded to Congress, leading Speaker Nancy Pelosi to launch a formal impeachment inquiry on September 24, 2019.
Key Political Figures in the Impeachment Saga
Nancy Pelosi: The Speaker of the House was a key figure who launched the formal impeachment inquiry after the whistleblower complaint emerged. She played a leading role in the investigation.
Adam Schiff: As Chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, Schiff managed much of the impeachment investigation, including witness interviews and subpoenas.
Jerry Nadler: The House Judiciary Committee Chairman helped draft the articles of impeachment against President Trump. His committee approved them, sending them to the full House vote.
The Ukraine Phone Call: Trigger for Controversy
The July 25th phone call between President Trump and President Zelenskyy was central to the impeachment saga. During the call, Trump asked Zelenskyy to "do us a favor" and investigate both a conspiracy theory regarding election interference as well as Trump's political rival Joe Biden and his son Hunter.
This request, and the fact that it came soon after Trump froze nearly $400 million in military aid to Ukraine, led to allegations that the President was soliciting foreign interference in the upcoming 2020 election for his own benefit.
The political uproar over the contents of the call ultimately triggered the House's impeachment inquiry into President Donald Trump's actions regarding Ukraine.
What was the impeachment vote against Trump?
The House of Representatives voted to impeach President Donald Trump on January 13, 2021, with 232 votes in favor and 197 votes against. This made Trump the first president in U.S. history to be impeached twice by the House.
The impeachment charges focused on Trump's role in inciting the violent insurrection at the U.S. Capitol on January 6. Specifically, the article of impeachment accused Trump of "incitement of insurrection" for his speech prior to the riot where he urged supporters to "fight like hell" against the election results.
All 222 House Democrats voted to impeach Trump, along with 10 Republicans, including House Republican Conference chairwoman Liz Cheney. In total, 218 of the 222 House Democrats had co-sponsored the article of impeachment prior to the vote, ensuring its passage.
While a majority voted to impeach, 197 Republicans opposed the measure, arguing it was unnecessary so close to the end of Trump's term or that his speech did not clearly call for violence.
Ultimately, the House determined Trump's actions warranted impeachment for "high crimes and misdemeanors." However, the Senate later acquitted Trump in his second impeachment trial.
The Impeachment Resolution and Articles of Impeachment
Drafting the Impeachment Resolution
The House Intelligence, Oversight and Reform, and Foreign Affairs Committees conducted closed-door depositions and public hearings regarding President Trump's dealings with Ukraine. They examined documents and heard testimony from key figures, gathering evidence to determine if Trump's actions warranted drafting articles of impeachment.
After amassing evidence, the committees worked together to draft a resolution outlining the articles of impeachment to be voted on by the full House. The draft resolution detailed the specific charges against Trump and the alleged impeachable offenses he committed.
Article I: Abuse of Power and the Ukraine Scandal
The first article accused Trump of abusing the power of his office by soliciting foreign interference to boost his 2020 reelection bid. It stated that Trump pressured Ukraine to publicly announce investigations that would damage his political rival Joe Biden, using $400 million in vital military aid and a coveted White House meeting as leverage.
Multiple witnesses testified that Trump, through his personal lawyer Rudy Giuliani, orchestrated a shadow foreign policy campaign toward Ukraine. Their aim was to coerce Ukraine's president into acceding to Trump's demands by withholding the aid and meeting.
Article II: Obstruction of Congress
The second article charged Trump with unlawfully obstructing the House's impeachment inquiry to cover up his misconduct. It alleged Trump directed defiance of House subpoenas for documents and testimony through an unprecedented, categorical, and indiscriminate blockade.
The article stated that Trump's obstruction of the House probe was consistent with his past efforts to undermine federal investigations into foreign interference in U.S. elections encompassing his 2016 campaign.
Impeached by the U.S. House of Representatives: The Historic Vote
On December 18, 2019, Trump was impeached in a mostly party line vote by the Democrat-controlled House. The abuse of power article passed 230-197, with all Republicans and 2 Democrats voting against it. The obstruction of Congress article passed 229-198, with 3 Democrats joining Republicans in opposition.
Trump became only the third president in U.S. history to be impeached by the House. The impeachment resolution then moved to the Senate for trial on whether to convict and remove Trump from office.
sbb-itb-585a0bc
sbb-itb-585a0bc
sbb-itb-585a0bc
The Senate Trial and Acquittal of President Trump
On February 5, 2020, the Senate voted to acquit President Donald Trump on two articles of impeachment - abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. This ended a highly contentious chapter in American politics surrounding allegations that Trump pressured Ukraine to investigate his political rival, former Vice President Joe Biden.
While the House of Representatives previously impeached Trump, the Senate trial did not result in his removal from office. The acquittal allows Trump to complete his term as president.
The Impeachment Managers' Case Against Trump
The House impeachment managers argued Trump abused his power by withholding military aid from Ukraine and pressuring Ukraine's president to investigate Biden. They stated this was for Trump's personal political gain rather than national interest.
They also accused Trump of obstructing Congress by directing staff and agencies to defy House subpoenas issued during the impeachment inquiry.
President Trump's Defense and the Role of Rudy Giuliani
Trump's defense team countered that the president had valid concerns about corruption in Ukraine and that his actions did not rise to an impeachable offense.
Rudy Giuliani, Trump's personal lawyer, pushed the theory that Biden had pressured Ukraine to fire a prosecutor investigating an energy company tied to his son Hunter. The defense argued Trump had legitimate reasons to request the investigation.
The Final Verdict: Trump Acquitted by the U.S. Senate
In the end, the Republican-controlled Senate voted 52-48 to acquit Trump of abuse of power and 53-47 to acquit him of obstruction of Congress.
While a majority voted to convict, it failed to reach the two-thirds supermajority required to remove a president per the U.S. Constitution. This allowed Trump to remain in office despite being impeached.
Mitt Romney's Defiance and the Bipartisan Vote
Senator Mitt Romney was the only Republican to break ranks, voting to convict Trump of abuse of power. He stated Trump was "guilty of an appalling abuse of public trust."
Romney's vote meant the final tally had bipartisan support, highlighting divisions even within Trump's own party on whether his Ukraine actions warranted removal from office.
Political Repercussions and the 2020 U.S. Presidential Election
Impeachment's Influence on the 2020 Election Campaigns
The impeachment of President Trump shaped the strategies and narratives of the 2020 presidential candidates in significant ways. On the Democratic side, some candidates like Joe Biden used the impeachment to reinforce their message that Trump was unfit for office and needed to be replaced. Other Democrats tread carefully on impeachment, wary of alienating more moderate voters.
Trump leaned heavily into impeachment in his messaging to his Republican base. He portrayed the process as a "witch hunt" and argued it was the Democrats' latest attempt to undermine his presidency after the Mueller probe. Trump used impeachment to galvanize his core supporters heading into the 2020 race.
Allegations of Foreign Interference in the 2020 United States Elections
The Trump-Ukraine scandal raised bipartisan concerns about continued foreign interference in US elections. Democrats warned that Trump's apparent openness to foreign help, as seen in his call with Ukraine's president, set a dangerous precedent. They pushed election security bills to guard against future foreign meddling.
Republicans countered that the FBI should investigate Ukraine's alleged intervention in the 2016 race to help Hillary Clinton. Trump and the GOP argued that the real election interference was from Ukraine and Democrats, not Russia.
The Biden Factor: Joe and Hunter Biden in the Eye of the Storm
The impeachment inquiry scrutinized Joe Biden's son Hunter's involvement with Ukrainian gas company Burisma while Joe was VP. Despite no evidence of wrongdoing, this gave Trump fodder to smear his potential 2020 rival as "corrupt." The GOP used impeachment proceedings to try tarnishing Biden.
Joe Biden had to play defense on his family's dealings in Ukraine amid Trump's unsubstantiated attacks. While the scrutiny didn't dampen Democratic primary voter support for Biden, it may have raised concerns for general election voters. Biden tried to redirect attention back to Trump's conduct.
The Second Impeachment: January 6 Capitol Attack and Its Fallout
Trump's rhetoric questioning Biden's win sparked the violent January 6 Capitol attack. This led the House to rapidly impeach Trump for "incitement of insurrection." But after Trump left office, the Senate acquitted him in his second impeachment trial.
The Capitol attack and Trump's post-election denialism left many Americans with grave concerns about the health of US democracy heading toward the 2024 race. Biden warned that the nation's democratic institutions had come under severe strain over the last four years.
Conclusion: Reflecting on the Legacy of Trump's Impeachment
The Enduring Controversy of Trump's Presidency and Impeachment
Trump's impeachment left a lasting impact on American politics. The allegations of abuse of power and obstruction of Congress fueled ongoing debates about the limits of presidential authority. Trump's fiery rhetoric and unconventional governing style also continued to divide public opinion.
While Trump was acquitted in the Senate, the impeachment inquiry shed light on concerning questions about foreign election influence and blurred lines between Trump's personal and political interests. These issues likely endured as themes in political discourse surrounding the Trump presidency.
Assessing the Impact on Trump's Presidency Post-Acquittal
After his acquittal by the Senate, Trump continued to firmly assert his innocence. He portrayed the impeachment as a partisan "witch hunt" and claimed total vindication.
Trump may have felt emboldened in his confrontational approach to politics and governance after impeachment. However, the controversy also consumed much of his political capital and attention.
The acquittal vote largely fell along party lines, affirming the polarization of Trump's presidency. Bipartisan governing likely remained a challenge for Trump post-impeachment.
Impeachment as a Political and Historical Precedent
Trump's impeachment left several key questions about the impeachment process itself. Debates emerged about what constitutes an impeachable offense and the standards of evidence required.
The highly partisan nature of Trump’s impeachment inquiry and Senate trial also set concerning precedent. Impeachment risks becoming another political weapon that escalates partisan warfare rather than a bipartisan process to uphold governance standards.
Nonetheless, Trump’s impeachment demonstrated that no president is above the law and that abuse of power has consequences. Future presidents will need to keep this precedent in mind.
