Federal Criminal Rule 45 Explained: Computing and Extending Time

published on 18 January 2024

Most legal professionals would agree that effectively managing deadlines is critical for federal criminal cases.

By properly understanding Federal Criminal Rule 45, you can accurately compute time and request extensions to help meet key procedural deadlines.

In this article, you'll get a detailed overview of Rule 45, including how to calculate days, what constitutes a reasonable time to comply, the criteria for obtaining extensions, and strategies to avoid missed deadlines.

Introduction to Federal Criminal Rule 45

Federal Criminal Rule 45 covers the computation and extension of time in federal criminal proceedings. This rule provides guidance on calculating deadlines and time periods specified in the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure or by a court order.

Here are some key things to know about Federal Criminal Rule 45:

  • It establishes methods for computing time periods in days, hours, or longer units. For example, it specifies how to count weekends and holidays when calculating deadlines.
  • The rule allows courts to extend deadlines for good cause with or without motion or notice if requested before the original time expires. This provides flexibility when unforeseen circumstances arise.
  • Federal Criminal Rule 45 aims to ensure fairness and consistency in federal criminal cases by standardizing time computation and extension rules.

Understanding Federal Criminal Rule 45 is important for anyone involved in federal criminal litigation. It governs critical case deadlines and provides a mechanism for adapting to special situations when meeting an original deadline becomes difficult or impossible. Following Rule 45 helps ensure compliance with court orders and procedural rules.

What is the reasonable time to comply with Rule 45?

FRCP 45 does not specify a minimum time period for compliance with a subpoena. However, in discovery, the issuing party typically allows up to 30 days after service to comply.

The issuing party may demand compliance within a shorter period if reasonable under the circumstances. For example, in Subair Sys., LLC v. Precisionaire, Inc., the court found that 6 calendar days was sufficient time to comply with a records subpoena.

When determining if a shortened compliance period is reasonable, courts consider factors such as:

  • The complexity and volume of records requested
  • The ease of access to the records
  • The business needs of the subpoenaed entity

Parties seeking a shortened compliance period should be prepared to show the request imposes no undue burden. Those objecting to an accelerated deadline must show they cannot reasonably comply within the proposed timeframe.

How do you calculate days in federal court?

To calculate days for deadlines in federal court, you follow Rule 45 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure (FRCP). Here are the key things to know:

  • Count every day, including weekends and holidays. Do not skip over weekends or federal holidays when computing time periods under the federal rules.
  • Include the last day of the period. If a filing deadline is 14 days, you would count day 1 as the day after filing and day 14 would be the last day to meet the deadline.
  • If the last day falls on a weekend or federal holiday, the period continues to the next business day. So if day 14 is a Saturday, the deadline moves to Monday (or Tuesday if Monday is a federal holiday).
  • "Days" means calendar days unless otherwise specified. The rules use "days" to mean calendar days.

So in short, you count every single day after the triggering event, including weekends and holidays all the way up to the last day. If that last day falls on a weekend or federal holiday, then you extend to the next business day to meet the deadline. Knowing precisely how to compute time ensures you do not miss critical filing deadlines in federal court.

What is Rule 26 Computing and extending time?

Rule 26(a) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure states that when computing any time period allowed by these rules, by any local rule, or by court order that is less than 7 days, intermediate Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays do not count towards the time period.

However, if the time period is 7 days or more, then intermediate Saturdays, Sundays, and legal holidays are counted.

For example, if you have a 3-day time period to respond to a motion, it would actually be 5 days because the weekend days would not count. But if you had a 7-day time period, then the weekend days would count.

The key things to know about Rule 26(a) time computations are:

  • Time periods less than 7 days exclude intermediate weekends and holidays
  • Time periods of 7 days or more include intermediate weekends and holidays
  • This rule applies to computing time allowed by the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, local court rules, or court orders

So in summary, Rule 26(a) provides guidance on whether weekends and holidays count when computing time periods for deadlines and responses under the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure and court procedures. It gives some leeway for short deadlines under a week.

What is the Federal Rule 45 Amendment?

The recent amendment to Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 45 is intended to simplify and streamline certain aspects of time computation and deadlines in federal criminal cases.

Specifically, the amendment does the following:

  • Clarifies that Rule 45's provisions on computing time apply in computing any time period specified in the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, local rules, court orders, or any applicable statute. This aims to standardize time computation across all aspects of federal criminal procedure.
  • Simplifies the method for extending time by allowing courts to extend time "for good cause." This replaces the previous "excusable neglect" standard which was more complex to apply. The change gives courts more flexibility in granting reasonable extensions.
  • Authorizes attorneys to issue subpoenas from any federal district court for criminal cases, no longer limiting them to issuing subpoenas from the court where the case originated. This amendment intends to ease some of the administrative burdens involved when attorneys practice law across multiple federal districts.

In summary, the Federal Rule 45 amendment aims to simplify federal criminal cases by standardizing time computation, relaxing standards for extensions, and enabling broader subpoena powers for practicing attorneys. The overall goal is to remove unnecessary procedural hurdles.


Understanding the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure

Overview of the Federal Criminal Rule 45

Rule 45 of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure provides guidance on computing and extending time periods specified in the rules or court orders. It establishes standards for calculating deadlines and allows courts discretion to extend time limits.

Some key aspects of Rule 45 include:

  • Establishing methods for counting days and computing time periods less than 11 days or more than 11 days
  • Accounting for weekends, holidays, and other non-business days when calculating deadlines
  • Allowing courts to extend filing deadlines in certain circumstances if good cause is shown
  • Limiting extensions for certain time-sensitive motions (e.g. new trial motion)

So in summary, Criminal Rule 45 aims to standardize time computation while providing some flexibility to adjust deadlines when warranted.

The Significance of Procedural Timelines in Criminal Procedure

Adhering to procedural timelines is critical in criminal cases. The swift administration of justice depends on cases progressing in an orderly fashion.

Some reasons why deadlines matter:

  • Ensure timely resolution of cases
  • Prevent unnecessary delays
  • Protect defendants' right to speedy trial
  • Maintain integrity of the courts
  • Keep cases moving forward

Rule 45 provides clarity around these timelines to support prompt case processing. It also recognizes that rigid deadlines are not always practical. The rule's extension provisions aim to balance efficiency with reasonable flexibility based on circumstances.

Overall, time limits create accountability while extensions provide latitude when justified. This framework drives cases to conclusion while allowing for obstacles beyond the parties' control.

Comparative Analysis with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure

There are similarities and differences in how Criminal Rule 45 and Civil Rule 6 handle time computation.

On similarities:

  • Both establish methods for counting days
  • Exclude weekends and holidays when calculating deadlines under 11 days
  • Allow deadline extensions for good cause

However, Criminal Rule 45 differs from Civil Rule 6 in a few key ways:

  • Stricter limits on extending time for new trial motions
  • Different standards for modifying some deadlines (e.g. service of indictment)
  • Varying rules around additional time after service by mail

So while the time computation logic is largely aligned between civil and criminal procedure, Criminal Rule 45 builds in more rigid constraints around certain deadlines viewed as especially time sensitive in the criminal context. This highlights how the accelerated pace of criminal matters is ingrained in the procedural rules.

Computing Time Under Federal Criminal Rule 45

Basic Time Computation Principles

Federal Criminal Rule 45 provides guidelines for computing time periods under the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure. Some key principles include:

  • Weekends and legal holidays are counted unless they are the last day of the time period. If the last day falls on a weekend or legal holiday, the time period continues to run until the next business day.
  • When a time period is stated in days or a longer unit of time, do not count the day of the event that triggers the period. Count the last day of the period.
  • Time periods of less than 11 days have different rules. Intermediate weekends and holidays are counted.
  • If the clerk's office is inaccessible on the last day of the filing period due to weather or other conditions, the time period continues to run until the clerk's office reopens.

Detailed Guide to Computing Time

Follow these steps to calculate time periods under Rule 45:

  • Identify the triggering event, like the date a motion is served. Do not count the trigger date.
  • Count forward each day, including weekends and holidays, unless the last day falls on a weekend or holiday.
  • If the time period is less than 11 days, count every day including intermediate weekends and holidays.
  • Do not count the trigger date but do count the last day of the period, unless it falls on a weekend or holiday. Then continue counting till the next business day.
  • Check if the clerk's office is closed on the last day. If so, continue counting till it reopens.

Applying Rule 5(b)(2)(C) to Electronic Filings

Rule 45 time computation is affected when filings are served electronically under Rule 5(b)(2)(C). Some key points:

  • The trigger event is when the electronic transmission is sent, not when received.
  • Add 3 calendar days to the prescribed period if served electronically. Intermediate weekends and holidays are counted.
  • The 3 extra days are not added if electronic service is made under Rule 59(c) (motion for new trial) or if a different time is set by court order.

Example Time Calculations

Here are some examples of counting days under Rule 45:

  • Motion served on Monday, August 1. 13-day response period. Count forward to August 15, the 13th day and last day which falls on a business day.
  • Order served electronically on Friday, September 9. 10-day response time. Add 3 calendar days so last day is Monday September 19, as intermediate weekend is counted.
  • 7-day period to respond to order served on Wednesday, June 15. Last day would be Tuesday, June 21 as intermediate weekend is counted.

Carefully following the time computation guidelines under Rule 45 ensures filings and responses are made within the permissible periods. Pay special attention to deadlines less than 11 days long and provisions for electronic service.

Extending Time Under Federal Criminal Rule 45

Federal Criminal Rule 45 provides guidance on computing and extending time periods and deadlines in federal criminal cases. This section examines the rules and limits around extending deadlines under Rule 45.

Criteria for Rule 45 Extensions

For a court to grant an extension of time under Rule 45, certain conditions must be met:

  • The request for extension must be made before the original deadline expires. Courts cannot retroactively extend expired deadlines.
  • The moving party must show "good cause" for needing more time. This depends on the specific circumstances but may involve reasons beyond the party's control.
  • The court must consider whether the opposing party would be prejudiced or harmed by an extension. If so, the extension may not be granted.

In deciding whether "good cause" exists and weighing potential prejudice, courts have broad discretion. Relevant factors include case complexity, scheduling conflicts, attorney workloads, health issues, or acts of nature like weather events.

Limits and Factors for Extensions

Rule 45 extensions are subject to certain limits:

  • Extensions cannot exceed 30 days after the original deadline if all parties consent.
  • Extensions cannot exceed 14 days after the original deadline if granted without consent.

In permitting extensions, courts may also consider:

  • How long the case has been pending already
  • The impact on case management deadlines
  • Whether it's a first-time extension request
  • If the need for more time was foreseeable earlier

Granting extensions requires balancing these factors against the justification for more time.

Understanding Rule 59(c) in the Context of Extensions

Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 59(c) sets a 14-day deadline for filing motions for a new trial. This deadline cannot be extended under Rule 45(b).

However, the 30-day consent and 14-day non-consent extension limits still apply to other deadlines under Rule 45, even in cases involving Rule 59 motions. So courts can still permit extensions for procedural requirements beyond filing the Rule 59 motion itself.

What Deadlines Can Be Extended

Rule 45 allows extensions for most non-jurisdictional procedural deadlines in a federal criminal case. This includes deadlines for things like:

  • Filing pretrial motions
  • Disclosure of expert witnesses
  • Responding to discovery requests
  • Filing notices and briefs related to appeals

However, courts cannot extend deadlines set by statute or alter expiration dates affecting substantive rights. So Rule 45 extensions focus on procedural time periods under court control.

Utilizing the Deadlines Chart for Time Management

The Federal Criminal Procedure Deadlines Chart outlines key deadlines for filing motions and taking actions in federal criminal cases. Understanding these deadlines can help legal teams stay organized and effectively manage their caseload.

Here are some tips for utilizing the deadlines chart:

  • Review the chart at the start of each new criminal case to understand the timeline and deadlines. Mark your calendar with any important dates.
  • Refer back to the chart when drafting motions or taking other case actions to ensure compliance with procedural rules.
  • Note any extended or shortened time periods that deviate from the standard deadlines per Rule 45.
  • Check the chart if you miss a deadline to determine if extensions may be available.

Keeping the deadlines chart on hand as a reference can help prevent missed deadlines and ensure cases proceed smoothly according to procedural timelines.

Comparing Criminal and Civil Deadlines

While civil and criminal procedure generally share similarities, there are some key differences in deadlines across civil versus criminal matters:

  • Motions for a new trial must be filed within 14 days after the verdict in criminal cases under Rule 33, while civil cases allow 28 days under Rule 59.
  • The time period for appeals also differs. In criminal cases, a notice of appeal must be filed within 14 days after the entry of judgement per Rule 4(b), while civil appeals allow 30 days under the civil procedural rules.
  • Service of subpoenas in criminal matters must be made at least 10 days prior to the court appearance per Criminal Rule 17(d), compared to 14 days for service of civil subpoenas under Civil Rule 45.

Familiarity with both civil and criminal procedural rules can prevent confusion when managing deadlines across different types of federal cases.

Practical Implications and Strategies

Tracking and Meeting Court Deadlines

When managing deadlines under Federal Criminal Rule 45, it is essential to carefully calculate and calendar all procedural time periods from the outset of a case. Here are some best practices:

  • As soon as you receive a court order, thoroughly review and identify any deadlines for responses or actions. Carefully compute the due dates based on the computation guidelines in Rule 45(a).
  • Immediately calendar all deadlines in your case management system, docketing software, or calendar with alerts set. Build in buffer time for drafting.
  • Set tickler reminders leading up to significant deadlines to allow preparations. Monitor your calendars regularly.
  • When calendaring deadlines, note what type of deadline it is under Rule 45 - is it keyed to an event like service or filing, or is it a fixed period after the court order? Understand how to properly calculate from the triggering event.
  • Note if the deadline is set by a local court rule or order versus the Federal Rules. Both should be followed but local rules control under Rule 57.
  • Consult the court's website for any special procedures, orders, or holiday schedules that may impact deadlines.

Requesting Extensions Effectively

If unable to meet a federal criminal deadline, promptly file a motion for an extension of time under Rule 45(b)(1). Here are some tips:

  • File extension requests as early as possible, before the original deadline transpires. Courts frown upon retroactive requests.
  • Specify the original deadline and the requested new deadline. Explain the rationale and good cause.
  • If you need an extension without a court order, stipulate with opposing counsel as permitted under Rule 45(b)(1)(A). Get approvals in writing.
  • Provide copies of documents showing circumstances beyond your control that warrant an extension, if applicable.
  • Request a definitive time period for the extension. Open-ended or indefinite requests may not be approved.

Avoiding Sanctions for Missed Deadlines

To avoid penalties for missing deadlines:

  • Carefully review orders for language warning of potential sanctions or consequences for non-compliance, including dismissal of claims.
  • If unable to comply with an order, promptly file for an extension before the deadline passes or risk sanctions.
  • Be aware that missing deadlines could result in claims being denied or dismissed with prejudice barring their refiling.
  • If a deadline is inadvertently missed, quickly file a motion to excuse the non-compliance, explaining the circumstances and reasons. However, sanctions are still possible. Avoid missed deadlines if at all possible.

Conclusion and Key Takeaways

Federal Criminal Rule 45 provides important guidelines for computing and extending time periods under federal criminal court procedures. Here are some key takeaways:

  • Rule 45(a) specifies how to compute time periods under the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, including when counting begins, weekends and holidays, and the last day of the period.
  • Under Rule 45(b), courts have discretion to extend deadlines for good cause or excusable neglect, even after the original deadline has expired.
  • Motions to extend deadlines should demonstrate good faith efforts to comply with the original timeline and provide a reasonable rationale for needing more time.
  • When seeking deadline extensions under Rule 45(b), earlier requests are more likely to be granted, while repetitive extensions face greater scrutiny.
  • Calendaring deadlines accurately from the outset and building in buffer time for contingencies can reduce the need for extensions.
  • Rule 45 provides an important but limited safety valve for timeline compliance - it should not be viewed as giving unlimited license to delay proceedings.

Understanding the provisions of Federal Criminal Rule 45 is essential for ensuring procedural timeliness while allowing flexibility when genuinely needed. Following the rule diligently helps facilitate the orderly and efficient administration of justice.

Related posts

Read more